Thamma reviews: How did netizens rate Ayushmann, Rashmika, Nawazuddin starrer horror-comedy?
- Richa Verma
- Oct 21, 2025
- 2 min read
The big Diwali release, Thamma, directed by Aditya Sarpotdar and produced under the Maddock Films horror-comedy universe, hit theatres on 21 October 2025. With heavyweights Ayushmann Khurrana, Rashmika Mandanna, and Nawazuddin Siddiqui leading the cast, the film generated high expectations. But how did the audience react when the first showings rolled out?
Praise for Performances & Festive Fun in Thamma
Many moviegoers praised the film as a family-friendly Diwali entertainer, frequently highlighting the lead performances and the film’s balance of humour and folklore. Film critic Taran Adarsh tweeted a positive verdict, calling Thamma “TERRIFIC” and praising its blend of humour, supernatural elements, and romance.
Audience accounts echoed this. Several X users called the movie a "perfect Diwali watch" and applauded Ayushmann and Rashmika for their energy.
Instagram reels and clips from theatre audiences also show packed houses and enthusiastic applause. Multiple reels from fan pages and Ayushmann’s own handle demonstrate the crowd’s reaction.
Some critics similarly gave it high marks for entertainment value; industry voices on X called it “a well-packaged entertainer” and praised the Maddock Horror-Comedy Universe continuity.
Mixed Reactions & Areas of Disappointment
It wasn’t all thumbs-up. Some netizens, via Business Today, labelled the film “the weakest Maddock film,” citing an uneven story and subpar visual effects. Others pointed out that the trailer had over-promised, with Moneycontrol reporting criticism around “lame jokes and forced meme comedy.” Several posts noted the film starts slow, the songs felt misplaced, and the horror jokes didn’t always land.
What the Netizens Agree On Thamma
The horror-comedy timing works better when it leans into folklore and laughs rather than pure scares.
The cast is a major draw; many feel the actors deliver beyond expectations. The film may not be flawless, but most agree it’s entertaining, especially for festive family viewing.
Some feel the Maddock universe might be losing its freshness if more films follow the same formula.
Crowd Pleaser with Flaws
In the netizen court, Thamma earns a mixed-positive verdict. Its festive timing, known faces, and folklore-driven narrative make it a strong weekend watch. But the plot, pace, and technical aspects leave a few fans wanting more.
If you’re looking for a film to enjoy with friends or family, especially this Diwali, it hits the mark. Just don’t expect perfect horror or high art. Think of it as a masala mixture of fear, fun, and festival energy.
For more movie reviews like these, keep reading through The ScreenLight.
