His and Hers review: When the truth is ugly, should it still be told?

His and Hers via Netflix

A woman is dead.

Her story is about to become national news.

But here’s the uncomfortable part- the person telling that story may not be telling the whole truth.

"His and Hers" opens with a murder that feels straightforward at first and then slowly it takes a twist, because the journalist covering the case has her own history with the town. The detective leading the investigation has a history with her. And every time the truth inches closer, someone quietly decides to push it away.

So here’s the question that hangs over the entire series: If revealing the truth could destroy you, would you still publish it?

And maybe more unsettling: who gets to decide what version of the truth survives?

Netflix’s "His and Hers" asks you to lean in, pay attention, and decide something for yourself. And once that question is planted, the show never really lets you leave.

His and Hers turns a simple crime into a moral trap

On the surface, "His and Hers" looks familiar. A murder in a quiet Georgia town. Police tape. News vans. Neighbours are insisting this kind of thing doesn’t happen here. We’ve seen this setup before.

But the show doesn’t stay comfortable for long.

Anna Andrews returns home as a journalist, but it’s obvious she’s not just back to do a job. She’s walking straight into unfinished business, old wounds, and a version of herself she never quite outran. Covering the case gives her direction. It also puts her uncomfortably close to things she might not be ready to face.

Then there’s Jack Harper, the detective on the case. Calm. Careful. And very aware that the woman pulling this story knows him better than anyone else in town. That’s where the tension really begins to settle in.

Is Anna following the story, or quietly steering it?

Is Jack protecting the investigation, or protecting Anna?

And when personal history crashes into professional duty, which one is supposed to win?

"His and Hers" don't answer these questions right away. It lets them sit there, heavy, making even ordinary conversations feel slightly dangerous.

His and Hers performances make every silence feel loud

Tessa Thompson plays Anna like someone who is always weighing her next move. She’s sharp and composed, but you can see the calculation happening, not in a sinister way but in a very humane way. She understands what the truth can cost because she’s paid that price before.

Jon Bernthal’s Jack carries his weight differently. He’s quieter, but a lot is sitting behind his eyes. Duty, guilt, loyalty, regret, all of it tangled together. When he speaks, he’s careful. When he doesn’t, it somehow says more.

Their scenes together are where His and Hers really come alive. Not through big confrontations, but through pauses. Looks that linger a second too long. Moments where you find yourself wondering: did they just protect each other, or did they just betray someone else?

There’s even a touch of dark, awkward humour at times. The kind that slips out when emotions get too uncomfortable to handle head-on.

His and Hers creates fear without ever raising its voice

His and Hers is not a jump-scare kind of scary, but it unsettles you differently.

It scares you with uncertainty. The slow kind. The kind that creeps in when you realise the truth isn’t something fixed, it's something shaped, bent, sometimes quietly edited.

And then there’s the uncomfortable part: the most dangerous decisions here aren’t loud or violent. They’re small. Private. Made behind closed doors, when no one is watching, and no one can interrupt.

His and Hers ending refuses to offer easy comfort

Without giving anything away, the final stretch of His and Hers makes sure every choice leaves a mark. Truths surface. Not neatly. Not gently. And definitely not without cost.

You may catch yourself asking uncomfortable questions: Was telling the truth the right decision here?

Did honesty actually help anyone, or did it just ease someone’s conscience?

And if everyone involved loses something, was justice ever really the goal?

The show doesn’t rush to answer you. It leaves you sitting with the discomfort, replaying moments, wondering how differently things might have turned out if even one choice had gone another way.

His and Hers: A Story That Won’t Let You Go

His and Hers isn’t something you half-watch while scrolling. It wants your attention. It wants you thinking, doubting, questioning. At times it’s slow, at times heavy, and occasionally frustrating, but that feels intentional.

If you’re looking for a clean mystery with tidy answers, this may test your patience. But if you’re drawn to stories about power, guilt, and the fragile nature of truth, this one stays with you.

Because long after the credits roll, one question keeps circling back:

If you were in her place, knowing exactly what it would cost, would you still tell the truth?

Follow The ScreenLight for more reviews like this.